Beautiful British ColumbiaSafeguarding the rights and interests of
Get Adobe Acrobat Reader

INDEX OF DECISIONS OF THE BRITISH COLUMBIA REVIEW BOARD

 

  1. Table of Decisions
  2. Subject Index of Decisions



I - TABLE OF DECISIONS

  1. WILLIE, BCRB Sep 30, 1992
  2. C.(J.) v. FPSC (BC), [1992] 65 BCLR (2nd) 3B6
  3. FISHER, [1992] B.C.R.B.D. No. 2
  4. R. v. TAYLOR (1992) 77 C.C.C. (3d) 551, 17 C.R. (4th) 371, 11 O.R. 323 (C.A.)
  5. BROWN, Douglas Harold BCRB July 30, 1993
  6. DH v. AGBC & FPSC, [1994] BCJ #2001
  7. LAJOIE v. QRB & AGQ ,( 1994) Q.C.A. #500-10-000200
  8. R.v. PECKHAM, [1994] OJ No.1995
  9. JOHNSON v. AGBC BCCA,Oct 1995 #CA020369
  10. PINET v. Ont, [1995] 100 CCC (3d) 343
  11. WONG, Larry, BCRB March 27, 1997
  12. DOUCET, {1997] B.C.R.B.D. No.
  13. JONES v. AGBC & Dir FPSSC, [1997] BCCA CA022969
  14. R v. VAUGHAN, [1997] ONCA C25187
  15. R. v. Arenburg, [1997] OJ No.2386
  16. CHAMBERS v. AGBC & Dir FPI, [1997] 116 CCC (3d) 406
  17. MONTEIRO, BCRB Sep 22, 1997
  18. VALE, Terry James - September 30, 1997
  19. HUTCHINSON v. Dir AFPS & AGBC, [1998] BCCA #CA024514
  20. R. v. CUERRIER, [1998] 2 S.C.R. 371
  21. DIXON, BCRB Mar 9, 1998
  22. KARIJUBA, BCRB May 29, 1998
  23. R.L.O., a young person [1998] B.C.R.B.D. No. 7
  24. LaFORTUNE, [1998] B.C.R.B.D. No. 1
  25. CLEMENT v. PENETANGUISHENE & AG ONT (1998) ONT. C.A. C29949
  26. FENTON, [1999] B.C.R.B.D. No. 28
  27. G.M.P. a.k.a. G.M.P., a young person[1999] B.C.R.B.D. No. 33
  28. GIELOW , [1999] B.C.R.B.D. No. 30
  29. MARTIN, BCRB Jun 2, 1999
  30. BEATTY, BCRB Jul 5, 1999
  31. HIND, BCRB Jul 6 1999
  32. BURRELL, BCRB Oct 6, 1999
  33. BRIGHTON, BCRB Oct 13, 1999
  34. FENTON, BCRB Oct 22, 1999
  35. MITCHELL, BCRB Oct 25, 1999
  36. BEAUDOIN, [1999] B.C.R.B.D. No. 27
  37. WINKO V. BRITISH COLUMBIA (FORENSIC PSYCHIATRIC INSTITUTE), [1999] 2 S.C.R. 625
  38. BOUCHER v. NB (RB), [1999] N.B.J. No 152
  39. SILVA, [1999] B.C.R.B.D. No. 31
  40. R. v. CAMPAGNA, [1999] S.C.B.C. #19990903
  41. BEAUCHAMP v. PENETANGUISHENE & AG ONT, [1999] O.J. No. 3156
  42. DOUCET v. AFPS (Dir), [2000] BCCA 0195
  43. MARTIN, BCCA May 29, 2000
  44. CHRISTIE, [2000] B.C.R.B.D. No. 220
  45. C.T.O., a young person [2000] B.C.R.B.D. No. 264
  46. J.A.D., a young person[2000] B.C.R.B.D. No. 10
  47. LAI, BCRB Nov 7, 2000
  48. R v. CHALMERS, (2001) ONT. C.A 20010122
  49. MITCHELL, BCRB Feb 7, 2001
  50. HUTCHINSON, [2001] B.C.R.B.D. No. 13
  51. RUSSELL, BCRB November 28, 2001
  52. MAZZEI, [2002] B.C.R.B.D. No. 99
  53. R. V. ROTHGARDT, [2002] BCJ No.2981
  54. HIND, BCRB February 4, 2003
  55. AUNE, BCRB Aug 21, 2003
  56. AUNE, BCRB Oct 8, 2003
  57. ALEXIS, [2003] B.C.R.B.D. No. 1
  58. R. v. MILLER, [2003] O.J. No. 3455
  59. R. v. OWEN, [2003] S.C.C. 33
  60. R. v. WILLIAMS, [2003] S.C.C.. 41
  61. PETERSON, BCRB October 12, 2004
  62. R. v. HUSSEIN & DWORNICK, [2004] O.S.J. Nov 10, 2004
  63. ORRU V. PENTANGUISHENE, [2004] O.J. #5203
  64. PENETANGUISHENE MENTAL HEALTH CENTRE V. ONTARIO (ATTORNEY GENERAL), [2004] SCC 20 (Tulikorpi)
  65. PINET v. ST. THOMAS PSYCHIATRIC HOSPITAL, [2004] SCC 21
  66. R. v. DEMERS, [2004] 2 S.C.R. 489, 2004 SCC 46
  67. R v. SIM, (2005) ONT.C.A. #20051020
  68. GIELZECKI, BCRB Feb 15, 2005
  69. LAROCQUE, BCRB Jul 8, 2005
  70. MAY v. FERNDALE, [2005] S.C.C. 82
  71. WONG, BCRB Dec 1, 2005
  72. KEARLY, OCJ Dec 15, 2005
  73. WILSON, BCRB Jan 04, 2006
  74. MAZZEI v. BRITISH COLUMBIA (Director of Adult Forensic Psychiatric Services), [2006] 1 S.C.R. 326, 2006 SCC
  75. R. v. VANCURENKO, (2006) ONT. C.A. 20060627
  76. WONG, PCBC July 10, 2006 #B41799-2-D
  77. MANITOBA (ATTORNEY GENERAL) v. WIEBE, July 31, 2006
  78. MCDONNELL v. EDGAR [2006] O.J. No.4293
  79. R. v. WILSON, (2006) SCBC 22464 (Publication Ban)
  80. WATTS, BCRB Oct 30, 2006
  81. PEREZ, BCRB Nov 20, 2006
  82. MAZZEI, Vernon Roy [2006] B.C.R.B.D. No. 93
  83. R. v. SHOKER, [2006] 2 S.C.R. 399, 2006 SCC 44 (Also: BCRB Chair's Memo Re Shoker)
  84. WATTS, Jason Kenneth 2006] B.C.R.B.D. No. 262
  85. H. H. A, a young person, BCRB Jan 23, 2007
  86. C.F.S, a young person, BCRB Feb 13, 2007
  87. XU, OCJ Apr 18, 2007
  88. V.O.E., a young person, BCRB April 26, 2007
  89. THIEMAN, BCRB May 7 & 28, 2007
  90. BEATTY, BCRB May 20, 2007
  91. R. v. ROYAL OTTAWA HEALTH CARE GROUP, A. LEYSHON-HUGHES and ONTARIO REVIEW BOARD, OSCJ No.12445 – May 31, 2007 (Also: BCRB Chair's Memo Re Leyshon-Hughes)
  92. FITZPATRICK, BCRB July 11, 2007
  93. MAZZEI, Vernon Roy [2007] B.C.R.B.D. No. 5
  94. SEYOUM, BCRB Aug 20, 2007
  95. LEE, Edwin Man Tsun, BCRB Aug 16, 2007
  96. BEGG, BCRB Sep 5, 2007
  97. SHACHTAY, BCRB Sep 7, 2007
  98. BROWN, Johnathan Allan, BCRB Sep 11, 2007
  99. KAROL, BCRB Sep 11, 2007
  100. WICKENHEISER, BCRB Sep 11, 2007
  101. R.A.S., a young person, BCRB Sep 21, 2007
  102. C.F.S., a young person, BCRB Oct 3, 2007
  103. JOHN, Ted BCRB Dec 20, 2007
  104. RANDHAWA, BCRB Feb 13, 2008
  105. C.F.S., a young person, BCRB Mar 19, 2008
  106. CHICKITE, BCRB Mar 27, 2008
  107. PHILLIPS, BCRB Apr 24, 2008
  108. BUGG, BCRB May 27, 2008
  109. PHILLIPS, BCRB Jun 18, 2008
  110. LEESON, BCRB Jul 17, 2008
  111. JOHN v. BRITISH COLUMBIA (Adult Forensic Psychiatric Services), 2008 BCCA 265
  112. HEIDEN, BCRB Aug 8, 2008
  113. WILD, BCRB Aug 22, 2008
  114. MDK, a young person, BCRB Sep 22, 2008
  115. SINGH, Mangal BCRB Dec 09, 2008
  116. STEELE, BCRB Dec 10, 2008
  117. BENNETT, BCRB Jan 09, 2009
  118. KOLODZIEY, BCRB Jan 13, 2009
  119. LYONS, BCRB Jan 14, 2009
  120. L'HIRONDELLE, BCRB Jan 26, 2009
  121. EVERS, BCRB Feb 02, 2009
  122. D'ALFONSO, BCRB Feb 04, 2009
  123. GERMAINE, Veronica Lydia, April 30, 2009, 2009 YKCA 3; Court of Appeal for the Yukon Territory
  124. HOOVER, BCRB Sep 15, 2009
  125. LUEDECKE, ORB Oct 6, 2009
  126. R. v. BREITWIESER, 2009 ONCA 784, Nov 9, 2009
  127. IRVING, BCRB Dec 1, 2009
  128. EVERS v. BRITISH COLUMBIA (Adult Forensic Psychiatric Services), 2009 BCCA 560
  129. SCHOENBORN, BCRB Apr 6, 2010
  130. R. v. CONWAY, 2010 SCC 22, June 11, 2010
  131. DAVIS, BCRB July 15, 2014
  132. LACERTE, BCRB July 15, 2014
  133. BARANYAIS, BCRB Sep 11, 2014
  134. WILSON, BCRB Sep 22, 2014
  135. MASSETTOE, BCRB Nov 6, 2014
  136. SZAJKOVICS, BCRB Jan 5, 2015
  137. STAETTER V. AGBC (Director of Adult FPH), 2015 BCCA 63
  138. LAROCHE, 2014 QCTAQ 09272
  139. Q.v.C.R. 2015 QCCQ 2299 (HRA Judgment)
  140. SCHOENBORN, BCRB Apr 30, 2015
  141. SCHOENBORN, DISPOSITION / WOC May 29, 2015
  142. NELSON, BCRB Jun 25, 2015
  143. SHORE, BCRB Jun 16, 2016
  144. MOODY, BCRB Jun 16, 2016
  145. CHRISTEA, BCRB Jun 30, 2016
  146. LAVIS, BCRB Jun 30, 2016
  147. GUTHRIE, BCRB Oct 3, 2016
  148. MARANDA, BCRB Nov 3, 2016
  149. CASD (AYP), BCRB Nov 17, 2016
  150. MLA (AYP), BCRB Nov 24, 2016
  151. INKSTER, BCRB Dec 13, 2016
  152. JRV, BCRB Jan 17, 2017
  153. MICKELOW, BCRB Jan 26, 2017
  154. HAU, BCRB Feb 22, 2017
  155. NELSON, BCRB Mar 13&14, 2017
  156. FARRELL, BCRB Mar 22, 2017
II - SUBJECT INDEX OF DECISIONS

 

1.0 REVIEW BOARDS (S.672.38 – S.672.44)

 

1.1 Establishment(s.672.38)

 

1.2 Quorum and Majority Vote (s.672.39, 672.41)

FENTON [1999] B.C.R.B.D. No. 28

 

1.3 Charter Jurisdiction

C. (J.) v. FPSC (BC) [1992] 65 BCLR (2 nd) 3B6

G.M.P. a.k.a. G.M.P. (a young person) [1999] B.C.R.B.D. No. 33

R. v. HUSSEIN & DWORNICK [2004] O.S.J. Nov 10, 2004

R. v. CONWAY, 2010 SCC 22, June 11, 2010

 

2.0 DISPOSITION HEARINGS

 

2.1 Jurisdictional effect of statutory Timelines (s.672.47; s672.81)

DOUCET [1997] B.C.R.B.D. No. 5

JONES v. AGBC & Dir FPSSC [1997] BCCA CA022969

R v. VAUGHAN [1997] ONCA C25187

HUTCHINSON v. Dir AFPS & AGBC [1998] BCCA #CA024514

FENTON BCRB Oct 22, 1999

GIELOW [1999] B.C.R.B.D. No. 30

MARTIN BCRB Jun 2, 1999

DOUCET v. AFPS (Dir) [2000] BCCA 0195

MARTIN BCCA May 29, 2000

 

2.2 Effective Date of Order/Disposition (s.672.63)

BEAUDOIN [1999] B.C.R.B.D. No. 27

JOHN, Ted BCRB Dec 20, 2007

JOHN v. BRITISH COLUMBIA (Adult Forensic Psychiatric Services), 2008 BCCA 265

 

2.3 Procedural Matters (672.1, 672.5(4))

 

(a) Parties and Status (s.672.1, s.672.5(4))

MAZZEI v. BRITISH COLUMBIA (DIRECTOR OF ADULT FORENSIC PSYCHIATRIC SERVICES), [2006] 1 S.C.R. 326, 2006 SCC

 

(b)Public Hearings and Exclusions

FISHER [1992] B.C.R.B.D. No. 2

WILLIE BCRB no Date

 

(c)Access to Disposition Information

BROWN BCRB July 30, 1993

R. v. Arenburg, [1997] OJ No.2386

AUNE, BCRB Aug 21, 2003

AUNE, BCRB Oct 8, 2003

 

 

2.4 Evidence and Nature of Hearings

 

(a) Inquisitorial Hearings

R.v. PECKHAM, [1994] OJ No.1995

CLEMENT v. PENETANGUISHENE & AG ONT (1998) ONT. C.A. C29949

BRIGHTON BCRB Oct 13, 1999

BOUCHER v. NB (RB) [1999] N.B.J. No 152

WINKO v. BRITISH COLUMBIA (FORENSIC PSYCHIATRIC INSTITUTE), [1999] 2 S.C.R. 625

R v. CHALMERS (2001) ONT. C.A 20010122

PETERSON, BCRB October 12, 2004

R. v. VANCURENKO, (2006) ONT. C.A. 20060627

MCDONNELL v. EDGAR [2006] O.J. No.4293

R. v. ROYAL OTTAWA HEALTH CARE GROUP, A. LEYSHON-HUGHES AND ONTARIO REVIEW BOARD, OSCJ No.12445 – May 31/07;

BCRB CHAIR'S MEMO, LEYSHON-HUGHES

 

(b) Aboriginal Accused

ALEXIS [2003] B.C.R.B.D. No. 1

R v. SIM (2005) ONT.C.A. #20051020

C.F.S., a young person, BCRB Oct 3, 2007

CHICKITE BCRB Mar 27, 2008

C.F.S., a young person, BCRB Mar 19, 2008

 

3.0 DISPOSITIONS, ORDERS AND CONDITIONS

 

3.1 Determination of “Significant Threat”

LAJOIE v. QRB & AGQ ( 1994) Q.C.A. #500-10-000200

DH v. AGBC & FPSC [1994] BCJ #2001

CHAMBERS v. AGBC & Dir FPI [1997] 116 CCC (3d) 406

R. v. CUERRIER [1998] 2 S.C.R. 371

WINKO v. BRITISH COLUMBIA (FORENSIC PSYCHIATRIC INSTITUTE), [1999] 2 S.C.R. 625

HIND BCRB Jul 6 1999

BEATTY BCRB Jul 5, 1999

BURRELL BCRB Oct 6, 1999

MITCHELL BCRB Oct 25, 1999

SILVA [1999] B.C.R.B.D. No. 31

R. v. CAMPAGNA [1999] S.C.B.C. #19990903

CHRISTIE [2000] B.C.R.B.D. No. 220

C.T.O. a young person [2000] B.C.R.B.D. No. 264

MITCHELL BCRB Feb 7, 2001

HUTCHINSON [2001] B.C.R.B.D. No. 13

HIND, BCRB Feb 4, 2003

R. v. MILLER [2003] O.J. No. 3455

R. v. OWEN [2003] S.C.C. 33

R. v. WILLIAMS [2003] S.C.C.. 41

SEYOUM BCRB Aug 20, 2007

BEATTY BCRB May 20, 2007

THIEMAN BCRB May 7 & 28, 2007

FITZPATRICK BCRB July 11, 2007

LEE, Edwin Man Tsun BCRB Aug 16, 2007

BEGG, BCRB Sep 5, 2007

BROWN Johnathan Allan, BCRB Sep 11, 2007

KAROL BCRB Sep 11, 2007

BUGG, BCRB May 27, 2008

WILD, BCRB Aug 22, 2008

MDK, a young person, BCRB Sep 22, 2008

SINGH, Mangal BCRB Dec 09, 2008

STEELE, BCRB Dec 10, 2008

KOLODZIEY, BCRB Jan 13, 2009

D'ALFONSO, BCRB Feb 04, 2009

LUEDECKE, ORB Oct 6, 2009

DAVIS, BCRB July 15, 2014

LACERTE, BCRB July 15, 2014

BARANYAIS, BCRB Sep 11, 2014

 

 

3.2 Standard of Proof

R.v. PECKHAM, [1994] OJ No.1995

WINKO v. BRITISH COLUMBIA (FORENSIC PSYCHIATRIC INSTITUTE), [1999] 2 S.C.R. 625

 

 

3.3 Least Onerous and Least Restrictive Disposition

JOHNSON v. AGBC BCCA Oct 1995 #CA020369

WINKO v. BRITISH COLUMBIA (FORENSIC PSYCHIATRIC INSTITUTE) [1999] 2 S.C.R. 625

ORRU v. PENTANGUISEINE [2004] O.J. #5203

PENETANGUISHENE MENTAL HEALTH CENTRE V. ONTARIO (ATTORNEY GENERAL) [2004] SCC 20 (Tulikorpi)

PINET v. ST. THOMAS PSYCHIATRIC HOSPITAL [2004] SCC 21

R.v. SHOKER [2006] 2 S.C.R. 399

BCRB CHAIR'S MEMO SHOKER

PEREZ BCRB Nov 20, 2006

LEESON, BCRB Jul 17, 2008

BENNETT, BCRB Jan 09, 2009

L'HIRONDELLE, BCRB Jan 26, 2009

EVERS, BCRB Feb 02, 2009

GERMAINE, Veronica Lydia, April 30, 2009, 2009 YKCA 3; Court of Appeal for the Yukon Territory

HOOVER, BCRB Sep 15, 2009

R. v. BREITWIESER, 2009 ONCA 784, Nov 9, 2009

IRVING, BCRB Dec 1, 2009

EVERS v. BRITISH COLUMBIA (Adult Forensic Psychiatric Services), 2009 BCCA 560

 

3.4 Powers and Authorities that May be Included

PINET v. ONT [1995] 100 CCC (3d) 343

DIXON BCRB Mar 9, 1998

WINKO v. BRITISH COLUMBIA (FORENSIC PSYCHIATRIC INSTITUTE) [1999] 2 S.C.R. 625

BEAUCHAMP v. PENETANGUISHENE & AG ONT [1999] O.J. No. 3156

CHRISTIE [2000] B.C.R.B.D. No. 220

MAZZEI [2002] B.C.R.B.D. No. 99

ORRU v. PENTANGUISHENE [2004] O.J. #5203

R. v. HUSSEIN & DWORNICK [2004] O.S.J. Nov 10, 2004

GIELZECKI BCRB Feb 15, 2005

MAZZEI [2006] B.C.R.B.D. No. 93

MAZZEI v. BRITISH COLUMBIA (DIRECTOR OF ADULT FORENSIC PSYCHIATRIC SERVICES) [2006] S.C.J. No. 7 CASCC - 2006 Mar 16 SCJ 83007

WATTS BCRB Oct 30, 2006

MAZZEI [2007] B.C.R.B.D. No. 5

C.F.S. a young person, BCRB Feb 13, 2007

LEESON, BCRB Jul 17, 2008

HOOVER, BCRB Sep 15, 2009

 

3.5 Delegation of Authorities (s.672.56)  

JOHNSON v. AGBC BCCA Oct 1995 #CA020369

VALE BCRB Sep 30, 1997

DIXON BCRB Mar 9, 1998

MITCHELL BCRB Feb 7, 2001

MAY v. FERNDALE [2005] S.C.C. 82

GIELZECKI BCRB Feb 15, 2005

WATTS BCRB Oct 30, 2006

MAZZEI [2006] S.C.J. No. 7, 2006 SCC 7

MAZZEI [2007] B.C.R.B.D. No. 5

HOOVER, BCRB Sep 15, 2009

 

3.6 “Mental Condition”

R.v. PECKHAM [1994] OJ No.1995

JONES v. AGBC 1997 BCCA

LUEDECKE, ORB Oct 6, 2009

 

4.0 FITNESS TO STAND TRIAL

 

4.1 Limited Cognitive Capacity

R. v. TAYLOR (1992) 77 C.C.C. (3d) 551, 17 C.R. (4th) 371, 11 O.R. 323 (C.A.)

WONG, Larry, BCRB March 27, 1997

MONTEIRO BCRB Sep 22, 1997

KARIJUBA, BCRB May 29, 1998

R.L.O. a young person [1998] B.C.R.B.D. No. 7

LaFORTUNE [1998] B.C.R.B.D. No. 1

LAI, BCRB Nov 7, 2000

RUSSELL, BCRB November 28, 2001

XU OCJ Apr 18, 2007

H. H. A Young Person BCRB Jan 23, 2007

V.O.E. a young person, BCRB April 26, 2007

SHACHTAY BCRB Sep 7, 2007

RANDHAWA BCRB Feb 13, 2008

HEIDEN, BCRB Aug 8, 2008

LYONS, BCRB Jan 14, 2009

EVERS, BCRB Feb 02, 2009

SCHOENBORN, BCRB Apr 6, 2010

 

4.2 Stay of Proceedings (Permanently Unfit Accused)  

R. v. DEMERS [2004] 2 S.C.R. 489, 2004 SCC 46

LAROCQUE BCRB Jul 8, 2005

WONG BCRB Dec 1, 2005

KEARLY OCJ Dec 15, 2005

WILSON, BCRB Jan 04, 2006

R. v. WILSON, (2006) SCBC 22464 (Publication Ban)

WONG PCBC July 10, 2006 #B41799-2-D

PHILLIPS BCRB Apr 24, 2008

PHILLIPS BCRB Jun 18, 2008

 

5.0 YOUTH/YOUTH CRIMINAL JUSTICE ACT

G.M.P. a.k.a. G.M.P., a young person [1999] B.C.R.B.D. No. 33

C.T.O. a young person [2000] BCRBD No. 264

J.A.D. a young person [2000] BCRBD No. 10

R.A.S. a young person BCRB Sep 21, 2007

C.F.S., a young person, BCRB Mar 19, 2008